Al Quran - Tafsir & By Word

Feedback on Updated English Tafsir Ibn Kathir (grouping of ayahs)

2y agoCompleted

Assalamu 'alaykum,

The tafsir for multiple ayahs are all gathered in one ayah.

For example the tafsir ibn kathir for Al-Haqqah for ayat 1-12 is on ayah 12. Before every ayah would have it's tafsir but now I find the tafsir for Ayah 1 on ayah 12.

Could you change it back to the way it was before, where every ayah had its own tafsir and not all the tafsir grouped up under one ayah?

Jazakallahu khairan

and 43 others

19 comments

  1. Assalamu 'alaykum wa rahmatullah brothers/sisters,

    I've shared a detailed comment about recent updates to English Tafsir Ibn Kathir data in [this post](https://feedback.gtaf.org/quran/p/feedback-on-updated-englis…)

    The updated data includes previously missing content and many corrections, making it more complete and aligned with the original published tafsir by Darussalam publication.

    Regarding ayah-by-ayah separation, the current format maintains the scholarly grouping of ayahs as found in the original source. This ensures the accuracy and completeness of the explanations as intended in the original tafsir.

    Tafsir for grouped ayahs is visible from any ayah within that group, eliminating the need to jump between the ayahs.

    But we are thinking of ways for how to improve the studying experience more in sha Allah. Feel free to share any suggestions.

  2. h_dubi882y ago

    Yes, I prefer after each ayah or smaller group of ayat which gives deeper understanding and better comprehension.

  3. jabarul2y ago

    Alternatively, Provide group by group tafsir, whereby relevant ayahs are grouped together and given single tafsir. Then move on to next group of ayahs.

  4. ecys52y ago

    I also saw some tafsirs are missing; for example, 11:80: I can't find it!

  5. Assalamu 'alaykum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh dear brothers and sisters,

    Alhamdulillah, we've released an update v1.29.4 to improve your reading experience with English Tafsir Ibn Kathir. We sincerely appreciate your patience and valuable feedback.

    What's improved:

    1. Better readability with proper spacing between paragraphs and words

    2. Arabic font restored to the previous style

    3. Tafsir for grouped ayahs is now visible from any ayah within that group, eliminating the need to jump between the ayahs

    **Important clarification:** English Tafsir Ibn Kathir has always been the abridged version by Darussalaam - both in our app and other platforms. We haven't abridged it with our recent updates. In fact, the new database includes some previously missing content and many corrections, making it more complete and aligned with the published book.

    Regarding ayah-by-ayah separation: The current format maintains the scholarly grouping of ayahs as found in the original Darussalam publication. This ensures the accuracy and completeness of the explanations as intended in the original tafsir.

    You can update the app here: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.greentech.…

    We're committed to continuous improvement while maintaining the authenticity of the tafsir.

    Your feedback helps us serve the Ummah better, jazakumullahu khairan.

    If you have any questions or suggestions, please feel free to share them with us.

  6. faiza6372y ago

    As salammoualaykoum wa rahmatoullah wa barkatouhou, bonsoir mes chers frères et sœurs. Juste pour informer après la mise a jour récente, la lecture audio c'est dégradé. Il y a des grabuge lors de la lecture.

  7. ecys52y ago

    Hi,

    I've just gotten update 1.29.4, and was hoping it would be reverted to how it was like before...

    But it just shows the same text for multiple verses, and line breaks are inconsistent when compared to how they were originally.

    If it is not reverted, then unfortunately I will have to downgrade to an older version of the app which still has the old tafsir, because it is too vital to let go, and one of the main reasons I use this app.

    • img/2klm5r9cfjuouip0rrp0i5uj
    1. ecys5asc akhi can you tell me how to downgrade jazzakallahu kheiran

    2. ecys52y ago

      abdihamimhirsi Yes. You can download an old version online by searching "al quran uptodown" google and selecting version 1.28.5. It has Tafsir Ibn Kathir the way it was before they changed it. Your GTAF account works fine and you can sync bookmarks/notes. :)

      Link: https://com-greentech-quran.en.uptodown.com/android/download…

      It also removes some new features such as your longest streak, etc... but i am not using it for tracking the streak! sooo, NOT interested!

  8. titi32y ago

    I hope that In'shaa'Allah the tafseer of ibn kathir will be brought back to normal and that we could chose between abridged and detailed. If it doesn't come back....unfortunately i will have to delete the app, because now there will be (for me) no point of using it anymore, i really loved the tafsir. May Allah make it easy for you, wa salam alaykum wa rahmatuLlahi wa barakatuh!

  9. lopir2y ago

    yes! 💘

  10. emiola2y ago

    This is the reason I'm giving the feedback, jazakhum llayhi khairan for saying it better than I can. Pls work on it

  11. ibiliyas2y ago

    Salam Alaykum!

    I left a review on the "Play Store" regarding the update on the "Abridged" tafsir of Ibn Kathir and I was replied to come here and leave a feedback and Alhamdulillah, I'm very happy that many of my brothers and sisters have made same reviews as I have in mind for reversing the tafsirs to each ayah.

    I've made comparison between the new update and the old version on my different two devices and saw that there has been some additions e.g The opening tafsir of Az-Zumar which is on ayah 4 has an Hadith of A'ishah(RA) which the old version does not have, jazakallahu khayran for that.

    Lastly, I humbly request that the old Arabic FONT for the tasfirs for "quoted verses and Hadiths" be reversed too along with each "verse with its tafsir".

    May Allah SWT who gives ease and success makes it easy for the team to implement these reviews, Amin. Jazakallahu khayran.

    • img/clwvj3bukqi6fqvm70i8wfzq
  12. Assalamualaikum akhi return the tafsiir back the way it was it was good can't say perfect perfection is for Allah only but it was really good the way it was jazzakallahu kheiran

  13. **Assalamu 'alaykum wa rahmatullah dear brothers and sisters,**

    We pray this message finds you in the best of health and Iman. Alhamdulillah, we recently rolled out an update to the English Tafsir Ibn Kathir in our Quran app, and while it brought many improvements, we have received valuable feedback from several of you about some issues.

    **First, we want to sincerely acknowledge your concerns and express our appreciation for your patience and input.**

    # A few important points:

    **Tafsir Ibn Kathir in English:** As some of you may know, the only available version in English is an abridged one, as published by Darussalam. While the Arabic version is more detailed, the English translation has always been abridged. You can find the Darussalam Tafsir Ibn Kathir (English, 10 volumes) hard-copy version [here](https://darussalam.uk/tafsir-ibn-kathir-english-10-volume-se…) or pdf from [here](https://kalamullah.com/tafsir-ibn-kathir.html).

    Additionally, **we are collaborating with Quran.com and Tarteel for Tafsir Ibn Kathir English data.** This is the same data used by many other Quran apps and websites, so rest assured that the information remains consistent across popular and reliable Quran apps.

    # What’s improved in the update:

    1. **More Complete Tafsir:** Several passages that were previously missing are now included. For example, in Surah Al-Fatiha (1:1), many introductory details were missing before, which we’ve now added to better align with the published book. The same is applicable in multiple other places.

    2. **Corrected Errors:** We've fixed many typos and other inconsistencies to ensure a more accurate reading experience.

    # However, we understand the challenges some of you are facing:

    1. **Cluttered Text and Spacing:** The lack of paragraph and line spacing has made reading difficult, and we agree this needs improvement. Alhamdulillah, we are working on fixing this as we speak. Soon, you’ll notice a better formatting, in sha Allah.

    2. **Merging Tafsirs of Multiple Ayahs:** We understand that many of you prefer a verse-by-verse explanation, which was easier to follow. In the new update, the text often includes tafsir of multiple ayahs together, which reflects how it is formatted in the original Tafsir Ibn Kathir book. However, we are actively considering how we can balance this with a more user-friendly structure.

    # Next Steps:

    Please rest assured that we are working hard to address these issues. Our goal is to provide you with the best possible experience for understanding the Qur'an, and your feedback is invaluable in helping us achieve that.

    We will keep you updated as we make further improvements. Jazakumullahu khairan for your continued support and for helping us improve.

    If you have any further suggestions, feel free to share them with us. Your input drives us to be better, in sha Allah.

    – Araf Mohammad Mahbub, Product Team

  14. save92y ago

    +++

  15. FahimKhan2y ago

    Please add ibn kathir abridged Bangla

  16. titi32y ago

    I agree with u on the point that it should be reverted back to normal, It's better how it was at the very beginning. The more detailed, the better we understand the verse. I HATE it abridged.

  17. seenan212y ago

    YES PLEASE FIX THIS ASAP!. The new update ruined this formatting