Al Quran - Tafsir & By Word

Some Reciters have extra recitations on Surat Al-Kahf ayah 14

1y agoPending

Some reciters e.g. Hussary, Sudaifi, etc. recitations adds extra recitations that isn't present in the text. I tried with Mohammad Ayoub and his recitation was to the point. But I don't get why some other's recitations add extra recitations which are not there in the text. Am I missing something?

6 comments

  1. Assalamu alaikum brother. I stumbled across your question when looking at this week's feedback. Brother, the reciters repeated the words due to Tajweed rules of Waqf. This is not an error or a technical problem. Look at the ayah where you noticed the reciter repeating words. The ayah will include the waqf sign meaning that it's better to continue. That's definitely what Shaykh Hussary did in Surah Al-Kahf ayah 14. The "better to continue" waqf is in that ayah. If the reciter runs out of breath he must go back a few words to an appropriate point in the ayah where he doesn't change the meaning of the ayah and then complete the ayah without pausing.

  2. Assalamu ‘Alaikum Wa Rahmatullahi Wa Barakatuh, muntasimulhaque

    JazakAllahu Khairan for bringing the issue to our attention. Could you please provide us with a bit more detailed information so we can look into it quickly?

    1. Is it happening only for this specific Ayah or any other as well?

    2. A screen recording of the issue (if possible) via google drive

    3. Device model, OS version, App version

    These would help us identify the problem more easily, Insha'Allah.

    1. Shahriar Arnob walikum assalam wa rahmatullah. Thanks for getting back.

      Screen recording might not help because the issue is with Quran recitations.

      But I'll tell you how you can reproduce this issue.

      Till now, I've faced this issue for two Surahs. And only one Reciters recitation was to the point for both these Ayahs. Others have the same issue in one or the other.

      I've found the issue in Surah Kahf ayah 14 and also in Surah Maidah ayah 3.

      To reproduce this issue, go to either of them. Then listen to a Quran recitation by any reciter. Probability is, at some point, you'll notice a slight repetition where there's no repetition in text.

      This happens in specific places for both Surahs and for almost all reciters, except for Ibrahim Al-Akhdar.

      I'm not sure why it's happening. Maybe it's a bug or another issue. But I'd sure would love to see it resolved.

      Thanks for the great work you guys are doing.

    2. muntasimulhaque: JazakAllahu Khairan for the detailed information. Please provide your **Device model, OS version, App version.** It would help us identify the problem more easily. Once we get all the information, we will review the content and make the necessary corrections, Insha’Allah.

      Please keep sharing such suggestions with us. It will help us to fix the mistakes gradually.

    3. Shahriar Arnob I'm using version 1.34.3 on Samsung Galaxy S23 with Android 16.

    4. BTW, my guess is it's not device specific issue. Rather, the issue is with audio. But I can be wrong.